"SODON" COVERS ANYTHING RELATED TO MONGOLIA

Sunday, April 8, 2018

Mongolia exploits children in the name of tradition

Yes, horse racing is an  old  tradition but there  is no proof that ancient Mongols ever used little children as jockeys. Yes, Mongolian children learn to ride a horse at a young age as 4 or 5 because horse riding is part of our traditional nomadic life style. But riding a horse in everyday life and riding a race horse are two different things.  So, I think that  "child jockey"  practice is  a new "tradition", maybe started around  1920s. The only reason to use children as  jockeys  is their light weight. Horse owner would look for children as light as possible, hence children younger ages are  preferred.   

Al Jazeera has published an interesting article and a video on aljazeera.com. Click HERE.
(https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/2017/08/mongolia-child-jockeys-risk-death-race-170826063128607.html)

Mongolia is also one of the countries where camel racing has also became a tradition although not popular  as in countries like Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Egypt, United Arab Emirates, Oman etc.
Child jockeys used to ride race camels in Saudi Arabia but now they have replaced  child jockeys with robots. They used to use younger children with lower weights so that the camels could run faster. Allegedly they used to keep so called "slave children" who were intentionally  malnourished for  that  purpose. After much critics and outrage Saudis have abolished this tradition.
Interestingly, in Mongolia only adults ride race camels.

So, there is no problem with camel racing  in Mongolia, but with horse racing there is. How bad  is it to our children? It is very dangerous to  their health and lives! According to law professor Munkhsaikhan O., Mongolian State University, in average  2 children would die every year.  Hundreds would fall from horses during  races, and many of them would get  injured, some seriously. 
His article can be read HERE (in Mongolian).

Since  horse owners prefer to  keep secret any information regarding any accident during races, many cases of injuries  are not reported, and that is why there are no complete statistics available for each year in the past. 

The data Munkhsaikhan found is:
17 deaths in 1996-2006,
2 deaths in 2006-2008,
6 deaths in 2012-2014, (some data shows 4 deaths in 2012-2014  and 6 deaths in 2015-2017).

In addition, every year 300 child jockeys suffer from injuries. The number of children who fall from horses during  racing is much higher.  Those 300 children  lose their ability to become  productive citizens in the future since they would become  invalids because of their injuries. This is a tragedy we can prevent! How? Very simple: Stop using children as jockeys. But we are still keeping  this dangerous practice which sometimes can turn out to be deadly,  and creating  literally an army of disabled people! 


"Dunjingarav 2018" horse race
At the  horse racing event called "Dunjingarav" on March 18, 2018, where one of the three races was carried out even in the dark, as you can see in the picture above, in total 16 children fell from horses and 3 of them were hospitalized.  One of these three was seriously injured, with his skull crashed, and he needed to go through a number of surgeries. 
There is an non-governmental organization called Mongolian Association of Horse Racing and Horse Trainers (MAHRHT)  which is responsible for organizing  horse races. The Ex-Speaker of the Mongolian Parliament, M.Enkhbold, a long-time President of MAHRHT, has stepped down recently due to critics regarding  Dunjingarav 2018 race event, mentioned above. He should have it done long time ago and should have worked on abolishing of this child jockey "tradition", but instead he kept silent for so many years and did nothing. Maybe, even though he is no more President of that organization, he still supports   child jockey "tradition." Since he has been for so many years the head of this organization, he is at least morally guilty and responsible for all deaths and injuries occurred in the past years. 




M.Enkhbold , Ex-Speaker of Mongolian Parliament (stepped down as long time  President of MAHRHT)

What do we need? We need to end this practice and change the rule ! We are hurting our children in the name of tradition. It is like encouraging and keeping an ancient practice  of female genital mutilation as tradition in some countries. Race horses should be ridden only by adults, jockeys 18 years old and up. Even though there are sufficient laws existing in Mongolia to protect children, child jockeys are not protected. These laws are falling short of international standards established by the Convention on the Rights of the Child.

According to THIS article , International Labor Organization (ILO) made an observation in 2015 and urged the Mongolian Government to take necessary measures in law and practice to ensure that no child under 18 years of age is employed as  horse jockey, but both the Government and the Parliament have been ignoring this advice because the MAHRHT is represented in both bodies very strong. 

It seems that UNICEF is helpless too. Even though it has a representation in Mongolia, UNICEF Mongolia, our children are still being put in harm's way. If UNICEF is helpless and cannot defend the rights of children as it declares proudly, one should not expect any positive results from all our governmental and non-governmental organization. 


Mongolia is one of the 196  parties, UN member countries, to sign the Convention on the Right of the Child, a human rights treaty. This Convention defines a child as any human being under the age of 18. Nations that ratify this Convention are bound to it by international law. So, Mongolia must follow this agreement too. But apparently  we do the opposite what in Article 19.1 of this Convention states, "Parties shall take all appropriate legislative , administrative, social and educational measures to protect the child from all forms of physical or mental violence, injury or abuse..."

Compliance is monitored by the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child but unfortunately it seems that the Committee does not do its job either. Every year in average 2 children would die and hundreds get injured! What other proof  does the Committee need? 

Governments of countries are required to report to this Committee on the child rights' situation in their country, but I am sure that our Government has been trying to whitewash the real situation. It must be some ways to enforce the Convention, otherwise it would be useless and become nothing but an empty declaration on papers. 

Here is one story telling about a child jockey who became a disabled person cause by the injuries after he fell from his horse during a race. Click  HERE  to read this story.

There  should not be any discussion but stopping the use of children as jockeys.  Protective gears of any kind are useless. It is about the bone, flesh and body of a child who is in a very sensitive, fragile phase of its development and growth, and that needs to be protected by not risking their health and lives. 

Last victim was a 10-year old boy who died from falling a horse during a training, in January 2019. At the first race carried out recently a horse without a jockey was seen crossing the finish line.The reporter mentioned that horse without a rider but by his tone he was more excited about horses finishing the race and said not a word about that child who fell and acted as if nothing serious  happened. That is the picture we need to change. According to the MAHRHT- schedule, approved by the Government , there are 8 big regional races to be carried out this year, in May and July. The main event of the year is of course the Mongol Naadam (traditional Mongol festival) where the best horses come together to the capital city to compete. There are going to be so many local races  after Naadam too.  All these combined, the numbers of horses and children riding these horses will be huge. How many children would  sacrifice their health and even lose their lives while racing, nobody knows. 

In conclusion one can say that Mongolia is not doing anything to abolish this harmful to children practice, thus violating international laws and acts. In my opinion, the Mongolian Government and Parliament can be obligated to do something only if UN and UNICEF put pressure on them, otherwise all non-governmental organization and citizens are too weak to lobby against this practice. Also lots of citizens side with those horse owners and trainers who brainwash people with lie.

I urge UN and UNICEF to take necessary measurements to force our responsible bodies and help our children! 




Tuesday, January 16, 2018

Mongolia sends a spy to South Korea

Khurts Bat
South Korea is about to receive the top spy of Mongolia as the Mongolian Ambassador to that country. The new Ambassador's name is Khurts Bat. He is lawyer and economist by profession. Born in 1969, he was the Head of the Mongolian General  Intelligence Agency (GIA) since November 2014. In the past, he worked as the first secretary in Mongolian Embassies in Turkey and Hungary and also chaired department and a unit within the GIA. He was also the Head of the Executive Office of the Mongolian National Security Council (MNSC) and the Deputy Commissioner General of the Independent Authority Against Corruption (IAAC) of Mongolia.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bat_Khurts



There was a lot of discussions and debates about his nomination. However,  the Parliament decided his fate behind  closed doors. Ironically, there was an open public hearing going on at the same time inside the Parliament's building when our MPs hurrying up to confirm his nomination next door.
The participants at this hearing have brought up many cases with Khurts Bat's involvements.  The initiator of this public hearing, MP Batzandan Jalbuu, is  one of many who says that Mr.Bat should not represent Mongolia in South Korea or any other country in that matter.  

Mr.Bat was accused of misusing his power and office to take revenge or persecute , or do favor to others by victimizing certain persons in the past. One example is that he punished a high ranking tax official (a Head of an Agency of General Department of Taxation named D.Enkhbat) because his wife's company was punished with heavy penalty for tax evasion. Mr.Bat had to pay also penalty because he failed to pay his income tax. D.Enkhbat claims that he was victimized for this reason. He was given 8 years prison sentence for some made-up offenses. Mr.Bat was not in Mongolia when his wife was penalized for tax evasions. At that time he was in prison in  Germany but   he took personal revenge on Mr.Enkhbat many years later. As the head of IAAC of Mongolia he misused his position to retaliate.  

The reason why he was in a German prison made some headlines in western media back then. He was in charge of a small team which carried out the abduction of Mr.Damiran , then a Mongolian citizen living in France. In May 2003, Damiran  was lured into a meeting with a woman he knew and then forcefully arrested and taken away in a car across France, through Belgium all the way to Germany. He was held in the basement of Mongolian Embassy in Berlin until he boarded the plane headed to Mongolia.  He was heavily drugged, put on  a wheelchair and with help of a fake diplomat passport under his name he could board the plane. Recently Mr.Bat mentioned that Mr.Damiran  was put on a plane with a help of German officials when he was questioned about that Damiran's case  on a TV talk show called "Censorless talk."  With that claim he seems to have an intention to make others believe that Damiran  was brought home with the help from his German counterparts. For more details, check this link:

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/the-honeytrap-the-kidnap-and-the-heathrow-arrest-plot-50jqjzvmqw9

But he lied because it was Germany which wanted him arrested for abduction. He was arrested at the  UK  airport in 2010 (7 years later since the kidnapping) when he arrived there on an alleged official business, as the Head of the MNSC.
The German prosecutors had issued a warranty for his kidnapping case in 2003 , and that is why he was arrested by British officials. The next year  Mr.Bat was extradited to Germany from where he was released later on before a state visit of German Chancellor Merkel to Mongolia.

Mr.Bat may have carried out an order from the Mongolian Government back then by abducting Mr.Damiran from France, so the Mongolian Government should be held responsible for victimizing Mr.Damiran who was tortured and later died. But it seems that Mr.Bat is not fit to be an Ambassador because of the  things he has done while  he worked as  Deputy Commissioner General of the IAAC.
At his nomination  hearing he scared everybody (MPs) by asking whether or not he should talk about certain MP's "secrets". It seems like he knows lots of things which MPs want to keep it secret from the public, and that was the reason how he quickly, and behind doors approved to be sent away to South Korea. For our MPs it's better that he stays away from Mongolia and the public.

So far the Mongolian President has not given him his approval yet , but South Korean side should know by now everything what was going on around Mr.Bat's nomination. As the host country, South Korea reserves  the right to refuse to accept him as a foreign Ambassador.  Especially somebody who has a bad reputation at home and abroad. An Ambassador should be a person who can represent his or her home country and the people.